Learn · Articles
A useful evaluation can still say stop
Would you pay for an evaluation that tells you to keep your current waste route?
01 · The case
An honest evaluation can still say stop
I think that can be money well spent.
If handling your biowaste is expensive or the current outlet is becoming unreliable, it makes sense to look for alternatives. Black soldier fly bioconversion may be one of them.
But the evaluation needs room to conclude that the current route is still the better choice.
02 · The questions
What the evaluation has to answer
I would want to know what the stream really costs to handle today. What material is actually available under the existing contracts? Which routes are lawful? What happens to the rejects and residues? And who would buy or use the outputs, on what terms?
Growing larvae answers one part of that question. It does not settle the business case.
03 · The next step
Making the next decision clearer
Sometimes the useful next step is a pilot. Sometimes it is a smaller test, a change to the existing arrangement, or a decision to stop before spending more.
That is how I want Manna's evaluation work to help: make the next decision clearer.
04 · The conversation
The conversation behind the work
I recently joined The Chief Uncensored for a conversation about Manna and the work behind it. The full interview is in the first comment.
What would you need to learn for “keep the current route” to feel like a useful result?
Keep exploring
Related topics and pages
- Is BSF the right answer for your biowaste stream? The evaluation I actually run — the five-question test for whether a stream clears the bar
- BSF business case evaluation — the process that separates working facilities from the headlines — the commodity-business frame an honest evaluation sits inside
- You have a biowaste problem. Could it actually become profitable? — the 3-step evaluation for whether a biowaste stream can pay
Read next
- Is BSF the right answer for your biowaste stream? The evaluation I actually run — the five-question test for whether a stream clears the bar
- BSF business case evaluation — the process that separates working facilities from the headlines — how a working BSF facility is separated from a headline
- What shows up first in a real biowaste case (it's almost never the biology) — the five non-biology issues that decide a case before larvae matter
- Before spending on design: the biowaste decision — the three practical outputs that turn the facts into a decision before design spending
Next step
Make the next decision clearer
Manna can help assemble what the stream costs to handle today, which routes are lawful and what the outputs can sell for, so the next decision is clearer.