What makes or breaks a BSF farming business? – key factors in developed vs. developing markets

BSF farming business has strong potential worldwide, but the business cases varies dramatically between Europe/North America and Africa/Southeast Asia/South America due to differences in labor costs, regulations, feedstock availability, and market demand. Below, we break down the critical success factors, and deal-breakers, in BSF farming business for each region.

Key factors in Europe & other developed markets

Regulatory hurdles

✅ Strict feed & waste regulations:
BSF meal approval: Permitted in EU aquaculture (2017), poultry/pigs (2021).
Substrate restrictions: Manure and certain food wastes are banned.
❌ Deal-breaker: Non-compliance with EU Novel Food or FDA/EFSA feed regulations can shut down operations.

High operating costs

✅ Automation is essential especially at factory level, high labor costs.
✅ Premium pricing possible (sustainability-driven buyers?).
❌ Deal-breaker: Inefficient processing or low larval yield makes production unprofitable.
❌ High competition for the substrate

Market demand & competition

✅ Strong demand from aquaculture, pet food, and organic farms.
✅ Government grants for circular economy projects.
❌ Deal-breaker: Over-reliance on a single buyer (e.g., one fish farm).

Key factors in Africa, SE Asia & other developing regions

Labor vs. automation

✅ Low-cost labor allows manual operations (no need for expensive equipment).
✅ Small-scale models work well (e.g., village-level BSF for poultry feed).
❌ Deal-breaker: Poor training leads to high larval mortality.
❌ Everyone is an expert in their own mind – the level of training available varies significantly

Feedstock availability & regulations

✅ Flexible substrate rules: Manure, market waste, and ag byproducts often allowed.
✅ Free/cheap inputs: Abundant food waste reduces costs.
❌ Deal-breaker: Contaminated waste (e.g., plastics, chemicals) ruins batches.

Market challenges

✅ Local livestock/poultry farms need affordable protein (replace fishmeal/soy).
✅ Frass fertilizer is in high demand for smallholder farms.
❌ Deal-Breaker: No clear buyer pipeline (farmers unaware of BSF benefits).
❌ Price must match existing soy- and fishmeal

How to succeed in each market

In developed markets:

✔ Invest in (semi-)automation to offset labor costs or use grants to employ basic level workforce.
✔ Secure feed/food certifications earl (EFSA, FDA, OMRI).
✔ Target high-margin buyers (pet food, organic farms).
✔ Small packages at retail outlets for premium price

In developing markets:

✔ Start small & train workers to reduce mortality rates.
✔ Partner with local waste collectors (markets, farms).
✔ Educate farmers on BSF benefits (demo plots, trials).
✔ Scale up only once existing level has peaked production levels.

Final takeaway

In Europe/North America, BSF farming businesses thrive on automation, regulatory compliance, and premium markets. In Africa/SE Asia, success depends on low-cost labor, flexible waste sourcing, and local feed demand.

Action steps:

Developed markets: Audit regulations before scaling.
Developing markets: Pilot with a small farm and handful of customers to prove ROI.

Do you already follow us in LinkedIn? We share insights and news about insect farming and BSF business daily in Manna Insect LinkedIn page, come and join the discussion!

Cover pic by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay.

Read also:
Building a professional level BSF farm for under $10,000
Climate control showdown: Find the right system for your BSF farm